diff --git a/src/duckstation-nogui/sdl_key_names.h b/src/duckstation-nogui/sdl_key_names.h
index 86e117c22..acf32e478 100644
--- a/src/duckstation-nogui/sdl_key_names.h
+++ b/src/duckstation-nogui/sdl_key_names.h
@@ -333,14 +333,22 @@ std::optional<u32> ParseKeyString(const std::string_view key_str)
       break;
 
     const std::string_view mod_part = key_str.substr(pos, plus_pos - pos);
+    
+    // Keypad in SDL is not a mod and should always be the last + in the string
+    bool known_mod = false;
     for (const SDLKeyModifierEntry& mod : s_sdl_key_modifiers)
     {
       if (mod_part == mod.name)
       {
         modifiers |= static_cast<int>(mod.mod);
+        known_mod = true;
         break;
       }
     }
+
+    if (!known_mod)
+      break;
+
     pos = plus_pos + 1;
   }
 
@@ -350,4 +358,4 @@ std::optional<u32> ParseKeyString(const std::string_view key_str)
 
   return static_cast<u32>(key_code.value()) | (modifiers << 16);
 }
-} // namespace SDLKeyNames
\ No newline at end of file
+} // namespace SDLKeyNames